How to Choose the Right Hot Water Heater for Your Home (Montréal & Québec Guide 2025)
Choosing a hot water heater in Québec is different than elsewhere in Canada.
We have:
-
Colder incoming water temperatures in winter
-
High electric usage due to Hydro-Québec incentives
-
Many duplex / triplex / condo housing layouts with limited mechanical room space
-
Strong availability of Canadian-built brands like Giant, GSW, and John Wood
This guide breaks down everything you need to know to choose the right system for Montréal-area homes.
1) What Types of Water Heaters Are Common in Québec?
| Type | How It Works | Pros | Considerations | Best Fit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Electric Tank (most common in Montréal) | Stores hot water in insulated tank | Low upfront cost, reliable, widely available | Higher operating cost than gas | Condos, apartments, Hydro-powered homes |
| Gas Tank | Burns natural gas to heat tank | Faster heating, lower operating cost | Requires gas line + proper venting | Single-family homes with natural gas |
| Tankless (On-Demand) | Heats water only when needed | Unlimited hot water, energy efficient | Higher upfront cost + requires sizing | Larger families, high usage homes |
| Heat Pump / Hybrid | Uses heat from air to heat water | 2–3× more efficient | Needs space + airflow | Basements / utility rooms |
✅ Most Montréal homes use electric tank systems.
✅ Homes with Gaz Métro / Énergir connections may choose gas tank or tankless.
2) What Size Water Heater Do Montréal Homes Need?
Because groundwater is colder in Québec, tanks and tankless units must be sized slightly larger.
| Number of People | Recommended Tank Size (Québec) |
|---|---|
| 1–2 people | 40 gallons |
| 3–4 people | 50 gallons |
| 5+ people | 60–80 gallons |
For tankless:
You must calculate peak flow rate + temperature rise (Montréal winter incoming water ~7°C).
Example:
3) Best Hot Water Heater Brands for Montréal & Québec
Giant Water Heaters (Made in Québec)
Location: Montréal, QC
Why Choose Giant:
-
Designed for cold Canadian water
-
Reliable, parts easily available in Québec
-
Strong service network
Popular Models
| Model | Type | Strength |
|---|---|---|
| Giant Electric Standard | Electric Tank | Affordable, durable |
| Giant Super Cascade | Gas | Fast recovery for large families |
| Giant Power Vent Series | Gas Power Vent | Efficient + great for renovations |
GSW Water Heaters
Location: Cambridge, Ontario
Why Montréal Homeowners Choose GSW:
-
Value pricing
-
Widely stocked at RONA, Home Depot, wholesalers
-
Good for landlord / rental replacement cycles
Models
| Model | Fuel | Best Use Case |
|---|---|---|
| GSW Atmospheric Gas | Gas | Basement installs with chimney vent |
| GSW Electric Standard | Electric | Condo + rental replacements |
| GSW Power Vent | Gas | Homes without chimney venting |
John Wood (A.O. Smith Group)
Location: Guelph, Ontario
Known For:
-
Long-lasting glass-lined interior tanks
-
Strong burner technology
-
Excellent warranty options
| Model | Type | Why It’s a Good Fit in Montréal |
|---|---|---|
| John Wood ProLine Electric | Electric Tank | Reliable, great for rental properties |
| ProLine Gas | Gas | Excellent recovery performance |
| Power Vent Gas | Gas Power Vent | Ideal in renovations & retrofits |
4) Electric vs Gas in Montréal
| Factor | Electric (Hydro-Québec) | Natural Gas (Énergir) |
|---|---|---|
| Operating Cost | Low–medium | Low |
| Upfront Cost | Low | Medium–High |
| Speed / Recovery | Slower | Faster |
| Environmental Impact | Low emissions (clean grid) | Higher emissions |
| Best Fit | Condos, duplexes, rentals | Single-family homes w/ existing gas |
➡️ If you already have gas service, choosing gas may lower monthly costs.
➡️ If you don’t have gas, electric is simplest and most economical.
5) Installation + Building Types in Montréal
| Home Type | Best System | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Montréal Apartment / Condo | Electric 40–60 gal tank | Quiet + no vent required |
| Duplex / Triplex with basement | Electric or Gas tank | Space + utility access |
| Single-family with Énergir gas | Gas tank or Tankless | Faster heating + lower cost |
| Modern new construction | Heat Pump Hybrid | Lower carbon footprint |
6) When Should You Replace Your Hot Water Heater? (Québec Conditions)
Replace if you notice:
-
Tank is 10–12+ years old
-
Rust-colored water
-
Water takes longer to heat
-
Tank is sweating, corroding, or leaking
-
You run out of hot water frequently
7) Local Montréal Buying & Support Resources
| Service Type | Provider / Option |
|---|---|
| Brand Information & Model Guidance | Hot Water Canada (comparison & sizing help) |
| Installation / Replacement | Local licensed plumbers (RBQ certified) |
| Utility Programs | Hydro-Québec, Énergir |
| Hardware Availability | RONA, Home Depot, Réno-Dépôt, Wolseley, Deschênes |
8) Quick Recommendation Summary
| If You Want… | Choose |
|---|---|
| Canadian-made reliability | Giant |
| Best value for replacements | GSW |
| Higher longevity & efficiency | John Wood |
| Endless hot water + long-term savings | Rinnai / Navien tankless |
Authoritative References
-
Natural Resources Canada – Water Heater Efficiency: https://www.nrcan.gc.ca/energy-efficiency
-
Hydro-Québec Residential Rates: https://www.hydroquebec.com/residential
-
Énergir Natural Gas Programs: https://energir.com
-
Giant Water Heaters: https://giantinc.com
-
John Wood / A.O. Smith Technical Resource: https://www.hotwater.com
-
GSW Water Heaters: https://www.gsw-wh.com
